✨ Let’s get into it ✨
💡 TLDR
Hear me out on this one—someone just taught TV shows how to listen to fans. Love Story, the Ryan Murphy series about JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy, faced a full-blown internet meltdown over its…
Hear me out on this one—someone just taught TV shows how to listen to fans. Love Story, the Ryan Murphy series about JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette Kennedy, faced a full-blown internet meltdown over its early costume choices. Wait, really? People actually cared enough to critique a TV show’s wardrobe? And instead of ignoring them, the showmakers fixed it? Yes. Yes, they did. And honestly, it’s kinda beautiful.
The initial set photos leaked, and fashion critics (and obsessed fans) called out the costumes as inauthentic. Sarah Pidgeon’s Carolyn Bessette looked like she’d stepped out of a 2000s mall aesthetic, not the 90s style icon she was. The show’s execs took the feedback seriously, though. “We had a bump in the summer,” producer Brad Simpson told Variety. So they brought in Rudy Mance, the costume designer behind Feud: Capote vs. The Swans. Mance isn’t just a designer—he’s a historian. He spent months studying Carolyn’s real outfits, even tracking down a Canadian collector with 30+ original pieces from the era. Sure, they couldn’t confirm every item was worn by Bessette, but they matched the era’s vibe perfectly.
The real challenge? Designing Carolyn’s early days, when there were no reference photos. “We were telling the story of how they met,” Mance explained. “She wasn’t a fashion icon yet—she was just… Carolyn.” For JFK Jr., it was easier: he was famous from birth. But for Carolyn, the show had to show her evolution. Her coats got bigger as her confidence grew, a subtle visual metaphor for her journey. And let’s talk about that Birkin—Mance basically beat the hell out of one to replicate Bessette’s distressed look. He even found a specific Prada bag via Etsy, after a wrong one nearly ruined a scene.
The takeaway? This isn’t just about looks—it’s about respect. The team wanted to honor Carolyn’s legacy, not just dress her up. And fans? They proved they’re not just critics—they’re collaborators. So, girlies, if you had a say in your favorite show’s wardrobe, would you take it? 💬
❓ People Also Ask
Who is the new costume designer for the *Love Story* reboot?
The new costume designer is not officially named yet, but fans are eagerly awaiting the announcement following the previous controversy.
Why did fans react to Carolyn Bessette’s outfit?
Fans reacted strongly due to dissatisfaction with her outfit, leading to calls for a costume designer change and sparking widespread online discussion.
💬 What do you think? Let us know in the comments! 👇